Manga like Christmas no Yoru ni.

Ranked by AniList's community-voted "readers also liked" data and how often forum discussions mention a title alongside Christmas no Yoru ni..

1. When She Smiled at Me… 60 2 community votes
2. Santa Girl 1 community votes
3. Happy Christmas 1 community votes
4. Goukon Aite wa Nikushoku Keikan!?: 26-sai Shojo wa Torawaretai 53 1 community votes
5. Hands Up, You're Mine 60 community pick

Ask Tsundoku for a personal pick

Tsundoku reads the actual forum threads and your own AniList history before it recommends anything — every answer shows its sources.